Phase 2: Build the literature and claim comparison ledger #123

Open
opened 2026-10-20 15:04:14 +02:00 by erikinkinen · 0 comments
Owner

Plan ID: P2-17
Record type: Tracking parent; no implementation PR
Scientific protocol: 2.2 · Backlog revision: 2.2.1
Specification: sections 2.2.
Source: AES_PHASES_2_6_PLAN.md, issue heading at line 4104.
Plan SHA-256: 8acdaeb52d6a94fcad7de64d64521cd465f608344d63560b45f9202f5af71212
Protocol snapshot: Download the complete governing plan.

Goal

Make central claims distinguishable from established results.

Retained requirements

  • P2-17.R1: Archive the section 2.2 searches, primary sources and inclusion/exclusion records.
  • P2-17.R2: Write claims.csv with exact prior results, proposed differences and evidence classes for all five papers.
  • P2-17.R3: Add validators for source identity, unresolved novelty and publication ownership.

Child issues

Closure

This is an AND tracking parent, not an implementation task. Close it only after every child is accepted and the original parent acceptance below is verified. A permitted not_applicable child needs the signed route decision required by section 17.4.

Every central claim has a closest-work comparison; generic history sensitivity and standard abstraction lemmas are not labeled new.

Execution and acceptance contract

Apply the governing semantic/data/statistical contracts in sections 3–5 and the relevant phase section, plus the section-11 checks applicable to this task. Section 17.4 defines the required acceptance evidence. Store the outcome and immutable prerequisite/input/output hashes at

artifacts/backlog/2.2.1/P2-17/acceptance.json.

Only explicit dependency and parent-closure edges govern readiness; numbering adds no predecessor dependency. Checkboxes are work/acceptance items, not commit quotas. Keep implementation changes independently reviewable using the existing PR template. Execution, review and gate tasks close with their evidence/decision records and a PR only when tracked artifacts change.

An unsupported scientific effect is a valid result. Missing correctness validation, invalid inference or absent required review is not completion. Do not change endpoints, matrices, margins, inference rules or sample sizes outside the protocol change-control process.

Native blocking dependencies below represent the child-closure requirements; the parent must never block its own children.

<!-- aes-plan-id: P2-17; backlog-revision: 2.2.1 --> **Plan ID:** `P2-17` **Record type:** Tracking parent; no implementation PR **Scientific protocol:** 2.2 · **Backlog revision:** 2.2.1 **Specification:** sections 2.2. **Source:** `AES_PHASES_2_6_PLAN.md`, issue heading at line 4104. **Plan SHA-256:** `8acdaeb52d6a94fcad7de64d64521cd465f608344d63560b45f9202f5af71212` **Protocol snapshot:** [Download the complete governing plan](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/attachments/31cb768b-4788-4e38-aba9-9d7f0d1ee16d). ## Goal Make central claims distinguishable from established results. ## Retained requirements - **P2-17.R1:** Archive the section 2.2 searches, primary sources and inclusion/exclusion records. - **P2-17.R2:** Write claims.csv with exact prior results, proposed differences and evidence classes for all five papers. - **P2-17.R3:** Add validators for source identity, unresolved novelty and publication ownership. ## Child issues - [ ] [P2-17-A (#124)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/124) — Archive literature searches and source identities - [ ] [P2-17-B (#125)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/125) — Compare csaI with its closest primary results - [ ] [P2-17-C (#126)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/126) — Compare csaII with its closest primary results - [ ] [P2-17-D (#127)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/127) — Compare csaIII with its closest primary results - [ ] [P2-17-E (#128)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/128) — Compare csaIV with its closest primary results - [ ] [P2-17-F (#129)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/129) — Compare csaV with its closest primary results - [ ] [P2-17-G (#130)](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erikinkinen/AES/issues/130) — Validate claim/source ownership records ## Closure This is an AND tracking parent, not an implementation task. Close it only after every child is accepted and the original parent acceptance below is verified. A permitted `not_applicable` child needs the signed route decision required by section 17.4. Every central claim has a closest-work comparison; generic history sensitivity and standard abstraction lemmas are not labeled new. ## Execution and acceptance contract Apply the governing semantic/data/statistical contracts in sections 3–5 and the relevant phase section, plus the section-11 checks applicable to this task. Section 17.4 defines the required acceptance evidence. Store the outcome and immutable prerequisite/input/output hashes at `artifacts/backlog/2.2.1/P2-17/acceptance.json`. Only explicit dependency and parent-closure edges govern readiness; numbering adds no predecessor dependency. Checkboxes are work/acceptance items, not commit quotas. Keep implementation changes independently reviewable using the existing PR template. Execution, review and gate tasks close with their evidence/decision records and a PR only when tracked artifacts change. An unsupported scientific effect is a valid result. Missing correctness validation, invalid inference or absent required review is not completion. Do not change endpoints, matrices, margins, inference rules or sample sizes outside the protocol change-control process. Native blocking dependencies below represent the child-closure requirements; the parent must never block its own children.
erikinkinen added this to the Phase 2 milestone 2026-10-20 15:04:14 +02:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Reference
erikinkinen/AES#123
No description provided.