[BUG] Ext corpus guard uses a stale interoperability scenario list #108

Closed
opened 2026-10-12 17:52:13 +02:00 by erikinkinen · 1 comment
Owner

Summary

The ext cross-corpus checker rejects the maintained interoperability group because it keeps an older copy of the scenario list. The existing ACL metadata scenario is missing from that copy, so CI stops before the VM catalog.

Reproduction

At Integration e108f76960cd6706134296fafd8209e41f50a12c, run:

bash tests/ext-cross-corpus.sh

Expected and actual behavior

Both corpus checkers should accept the same ordered group. Instead, the cross-corpus checker raises ValueError: scenario group drift for ext-interoperability-corpus and exits 1. Its expected list has five entries; the maintained group has six, including subsystem-ext4-acl-metadata-positive.toml.

Environment and identity

Linux host gate in Integration CI 2473. No guest execution is needed to reproduce this failure.

Evidence and prior checks

ext_interop_corpus.TARGETED_VM_SCENARIOS already matches the group. The ACL scenario has its own positive/mutation matrix entry, supported media variant and explicit writable runtime profile. The stale copy is in ext_cross_corpus.SCENARIO_GROUPS.

Tracking

Use the authoritative interoperability list and retain exact ordered comparison. Both real group checkers must refuse omitted, reordered and extra entries; the cross-corpus checker must still refuse a missing referenced scenario file.

## Summary The ext cross-corpus checker rejects the maintained interoperability group because it keeps an older copy of the scenario list. The existing ACL metadata scenario is missing from that copy, so CI stops before the VM catalog. ## Reproduction At Integration `e108f76960cd6706134296fafd8209e41f50a12c`, run: ```sh bash tests/ext-cross-corpus.sh ``` ## Expected and actual behavior Both corpus checkers should accept the same ordered group. Instead, the cross-corpus checker raises `ValueError: scenario group drift for ext-interoperability-corpus` and exits 1. Its expected list has five entries; the maintained group has six, including `subsystem-ext4-acl-metadata-positive.toml`. ## Environment and identity Linux host gate in [Integration CI 2473](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/2473). No guest execution is needed to reproduce this failure. ## Evidence and prior checks `ext_interop_corpus.TARGETED_VM_SCENARIOS` already matches the group. The ACL scenario has its own positive/mutation matrix entry, supported media variant and explicit writable runtime profile. The stale copy is in `ext_cross_corpus.SCENARIO_GROUPS`. ## Tracking Use the authoritative interoperability list and retain exact ordered comparison. Both real group checkers must refuse omitted, reordered and extra entries; the cross-corpus checker must still refuse a missing referenced scenario file.
Author
Owner

The fix reuses the maintained interoperability list. Both real checkers accept the complete group and refuse omitted, reordered or extra entries; the cross-corpus checker also refuses a missing referenced file.

The [fix](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/commit/ef2f0a5583bfffebdd6b71a71643b3c9fb1d79f8) reuses the maintained interoperability list. Both real checkers accept the complete group and refuse omitted, reordered or extra entries; the cross-corpus checker also refuses a missing referenced file.
erikinkinen added this to the Alpha 1 milestone 2026-10-30 09:39:16 +01:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
erix/integration#108
No description provided.