[BUG] Rootd's retained helper selects conflicting library revisions #112

Closed
opened 2026-10-12 20:43:09 +02:00 by erikinkinen · 1 comment
Owner

Summary

Updating Rootd's library pins while retaining an older compiled Integration
helper makes its dependency graph inconsistent. The maintained selector refuses
before Rootd can build.

Reproduction

Select Rootd 783b15f5e1c945442150f474d8023028a5db32c4 and Integration
ba4dc84d82ac13f8f903d89a172c362c11642735 in adjacent clean checkouts. From
Integration, run scripts/setup-component-ci-overrides.sh ../rootd.

Expected and actual behavior

The complete transitive graph should select one original revision for each
shared library. Instead, the selector exits 1 with conflicting LibBootstrap
revisions 1ee28ed508014edc8d3c29fe8b0dbdf458849777 and
566a3b6451fde48ff440a70874a1dbdd2eea9ec5. The older selection comes from
Rootd's retained helper e108f76960cd6706134296fafd8209e41f50a12c.

Environment and identity

This is host-side dependency preparation on Linux x86-64, before compilation or
guest execution. The selected commits above are signed original sources. Rootd
c3914fd219a71779b43ef02fc05290b42246df07 with its previous matching library
graph is the last checked working baseline. No runtime authority is involved.

Evidence and prior checks

The actual signed Rootd checkout reproduces the selector's conflicting-revision
error. Its refusal is correct. An earlier raw-archive driver was rejected for
lacking original tracked Git custody and is separate from this valid reproduction.

Tracking

Phase 6,
Integration implementation
and Rootd.
Select and compile the independently signed helper with matching Cargo inputs
before updating Rootd, then refresh its catalog selection. Unchanged helper Rust
code does not justify retaining conflicting dependency identities.

## Summary Updating Rootd's library pins while retaining an older compiled Integration helper makes its dependency graph inconsistent. The maintained selector refuses before Rootd can build. ## Reproduction Select Rootd `783b15f5e1c945442150f474d8023028a5db32c4` and Integration `ba4dc84d82ac13f8f903d89a172c362c11642735` in adjacent clean checkouts. From Integration, run `scripts/setup-component-ci-overrides.sh ../rootd`. ## Expected and actual behavior The complete transitive graph should select one original revision for each shared library. Instead, the selector exits 1 with conflicting LibBootstrap revisions `1ee28ed508014edc8d3c29fe8b0dbdf458849777` and `566a3b6451fde48ff440a70874a1dbdd2eea9ec5`. The older selection comes from Rootd's retained helper `e108f76960cd6706134296fafd8209e41f50a12c`. ## Environment and identity This is host-side dependency preparation on Linux x86-64, before compilation or guest execution. The selected commits above are signed original sources. Rootd `c3914fd219a71779b43ef02fc05290b42246df07` with its previous matching library graph is the last checked working baseline. No runtime authority is involved. ## Evidence and prior checks The actual signed Rootd checkout reproduces the selector's conflicting-revision error. Its refusal is correct. An earlier raw-archive driver was rejected for lacking original tracked Git custody and is separate from this valid reproduction. ## Tracking [Phase 6](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/issues/65), [Integration implementation](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/pulls/12) and [Rootd](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/rootd). Select and compile the independently signed helper with matching Cargo inputs before updating Rootd, then refresh its catalog selection. Unchanged helper Rust code does not justify retaining conflicting dependency identities.
Author
Owner

Fixed by the coherent helper selection and Rootd pin. The helper compiles before its consumer is selected, and the dependency selector now resolves one original revision per shared library. Rootd retains its 277,768-byte baseline under matching compiler, source and cache locations. The relocated checkout observation is retained separately because embedded build paths change its size.

Fixed by the [coherent helper selection](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/commit/ea613b973d4f78fe5fb9467d593312f2bae94783) and [Rootd pin](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/rootd/commit/5b294e8be912acd41a5258295380bfe71ce4de4a). The helper compiles before its consumer is selected, and the dependency selector now resolves one original revision per shared library. Rootd retains its 277,768-byte baseline under matching compiler, source and cache locations. The relocated checkout observation is retained separately because embedded build paths change its size.
erikinkinen added this to the Alpha 1 milestone 2026-10-30 09:39:16 +01:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
erix/integration#112
No description provided.