[BUG] Validation-only Start refusal prematurely retains mediator rollback #12

Open
opened 2026-10-12 13:43:20 +02:00 by erikinkinen · 0 comments
Owner

Summary

Validation-only Start refusal prematurely retains mediator rollback. Maintained validation cannot reach its intended successful boundary.

Reproduction

Run the existing descriptor_envelope_refuses_out_of_bounds_or_changed_client_context_before_start control. After provisioning its original client, change the retained descriptor count, context or digest and send the authenticated supervisor Start request. The original failing source and current repairs are distinct; failures and true exit statuses are retained.

Expected and actual behavior

A validation-only refusal must preserve the original stopped mediator and client, without native Control, Cleanup or SUBMIT effects. Start retains staged rollback before pure client-set validation. A DENIED validation result then triggers cleanup of the original stopped mediator even though no native Start has occurred. This is a cleanup regression involving the original authenticated supervisor and its owned child; no foreign target or additional authority is selected.

Environment and identity

  • Component repository/revision and Integration source graph: original procd source, original Integration graph.
  • Image profile, digest and build/runtime configuration: maintained host validation and selected component workflow; no guest image is claimed by this report.
  • Hardware or VM, architecture, firmware and toolchain versions: x86_64 host with the workflow-selected toolchain; no hardware or firmware-specific cause is inferred.
  • Input/session route and granted authority relevant to reproduction: explicit source graph and local validation inputs; no additional runtime authority is introduced.
  • Last known working revision, if known: not established.

Evidence and prior checks

Retain rollback after all pure Start checks and immediately before the native Start attempt. Preserve the five existing refusal controls, exact original supervisor/child identity and partial-effect cleanup. Fresh source validation runs alongside independent implementation; no pending test is reported as passed.

Tests and exact-head CI now run in parallel with implementation. A skipped, pending or unrun check is not a pass; independent source work continues while regressions are repaired.

Tracking

Phase completion tracks the full remaining goal. Signed source fixes, coherent dependency adoption and exact validation results will be recorded before closure.

## Summary Validation-only Start refusal prematurely retains mediator rollback. Maintained validation cannot reach its intended successful boundary. ## Reproduction Run the existing descriptor_envelope_refuses_out_of_bounds_or_changed_client_context_before_start control. After provisioning its original client, change the retained descriptor count, context or digest and send the authenticated supervisor Start request. The original failing source and current repairs are distinct; failures and true exit statuses are retained. ## Expected and actual behavior A validation-only refusal must preserve the original stopped mediator and client, without native Control, Cleanup or SUBMIT effects. Start retains staged rollback before pure client-set validation. A DENIED validation result then triggers cleanup of the original stopped mediator even though no native Start has occurred. This is a cleanup regression involving the original authenticated supervisor and its owned child; no foreign target or additional authority is selected. ## Environment and identity - Component repository/revision and Integration source graph: [original procd source](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/procd/commit/253d4107459690d6483205db8d588b2a30d17a70), [original Integration graph](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/commit/a615de2f69c25d4575d0c349757a0017082f988b). - Image profile, digest and build/runtime configuration: maintained host validation and selected component workflow; no guest image is claimed by this report. - Hardware or VM, architecture, firmware and toolchain versions: x86_64 host with the workflow-selected toolchain; no hardware or firmware-specific cause is inferred. - Input/session route and granted authority relevant to reproduction: explicit source graph and local validation inputs; no additional runtime authority is introduced. - Last known working revision, if known: not established. ## Evidence and prior checks Retain rollback after all pure Start checks and immediately before the native Start attempt. Preserve the five existing refusal controls, exact original supervisor/child identity and partial-effect cleanup. Fresh source validation runs alongside independent implementation; no pending test is reported as passed. Tests and exact-head CI now run in parallel with implementation. A skipped, pending or unrun check is not a pass; independent source work continues while regressions are repaired. ## Tracking [Phase completion](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/issues/65) tracks the full remaining goal. Signed source fixes, coherent dependency adoption and exact validation results will be recorded before closure.
erikinkinen added this to the Alpha 1 milestone 2026-10-30 09:35:10 +01:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
erix/procd#12
No description provided.