Verify replay and snapshot parent acceptance (P2-08) #645
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
bug
cli
core
docs
event
experiment
figure
invariant
metrics
oracle
phase-0
phase-1
phase-2
phase-3
phase-4
phase-5
phase-6
provenance
revocation
tests
workload
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set
Reference
erikinkinen/AES!645
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "phase2/p2-08-replay-acceptance"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Task
Closes #96. Plan ID: P2-08. This is the tracking-parent acceptance PR required by the owner's one-PR-per-issue instruction.
Summary
Verify and record closure of P2-08-A (#97 / PR #640), P2-08-B (#98 / PR #643), and P2-08-C (#99 / PR #644). The original parent condition is satisfied: live execution, complete replay, streamed compressed replay and checkpoint resume agree on complete final canonical execution and analytical-archive bytes.
Scope
Add a historical-source/evidence checker, requirement-coverage documentation and the parent acceptance record. Verify immutable child source/output/prerequisite identities, ZIP/log/toolchain/JUnit hashes, complete test suites, the fixed-library cross-build artifact fingerprint and every targeted tamper rejection gate. Production code and scientific protocols are unchanged.
Design intent
The checker reads each child's historical source objects, so later changes to shared files do not invalidate earlier acceptance identities. Separate hashes protect operational execution and analytical D. Trusted checkpoint provenance and complete-prefix verification remain explicit requirements; acceleration snapshots are not modeled recovery.
Phase discipline
This closes implementation infrastructure. Immutable tapes, production campaigns, formal results, independent scholarly reviews, csaI completion and the required Phase 5 recovery supplement retain their own gates. The owner explicitly requires a branch and PR for tracking parents despite the older no-implementation-PR wording in the original plan.
Verification
All three children are live closed through merged signed PRs, with all eight successful pre-merge Forgejo contexts preserved. Their nine archived Debug/Release/Clang ASan/UBSan suites verify 654 recorded test executions. These are reused child results, not new scientific observations.
The parent checker at signed source
992ce34435e0afebd2049c2c01ef252831cfbdebpasses intact evidence and rejects a deliberately corrupted child ZIP. It verifies all 105 targeted tamper rejections per configuration from separately hashed full CTest logs, including the distinct cursor-continuity gate, and the four corpus-checker integrity probes. All eight local hooks and the frozen scope/source checks pass.Parent source/archive verification, corruption probe and live child closure evidence. Acceptance and input/output hashes are recorded in
artifacts/backlog/2.2.1/P2-08/.All eight final-head Forgejo checks must pass before the parent's three child-checklist entries are checked once and the PR merges.