[BUG] Canonical release-image CI gate fails before evidence parsing #47

Open
opened 2026-09-14 07:36:09 +02:00 by erikinkinen · 0 comments
Owner

Summary

The canonical release-image gate returns wrapper status 1 in CI 1595 and CI 1602, after all 486 catalog scenarios, canonical development boot and both native-ls input routes pass. Later interactive release gates are not reached. The underlying runner stage and cause remain unknown.

Reproduction

Observed in retained original CI; no new VM rerun or failure-frequency estimate.

./tests/release-image-interactive-vm.sh

The original workflow prepares its pinned graph and packaged release disk first. The wrapper delegates to canonical-image-vm.sh release, uses a private writable disk and matching OVMF pair, and selects the physical canonical-shell profile.

Expected and actual behavior

Expected behavior is a successful canonical release boot and evidence validation. Actual output is error: canonical image VM failed with status 1. The canonical wrapper returns before its evidence parser. The available public log does not identify an injector exit, stall, raw QEMU exit or failed guest command.

Environment and identity

  • CI 1595, push, original Integration 37299e719d7662698593c6d3be24752309bed7ec.
  • CI 1602, pull_request, original Integration 47c27a1614c02323db7bbebfdbd0ca6b09bc9d45.

The workflow selects its original pinned component graph and x86_64 QEMU/OVMF images. Complete CI logs and original wrappers were inspected. Image/firmware artifact bytes and inner runner receipts were not downloaded; their exact digests and the guest cause remain unverified. Existing 120-second total, 15-second serial-progress and 10-second input-command limits remain unchanged.

Evidence and prior checks

Complete original CI review — 28 September 2026:

These are additional original observations. No unchanged job was rerun, and an identical underlying cause to earlier observations is not assumed.

  • CI1820, c5958f12daf35ef8c53d8caabaa7429340770179: Canonical release image wrapper exits 1 before evidence parsing; inner failure stage is unavailable. Three complete logs contain 13,457,954 bytes and zero warning candidates. Rust and Markdown pass.

The retained errors occur at 09:30:30 UTC in CI 1595 and 13:15:03 UTC in CI 1602 on September 13. Independent push CI 1601 passes at the same source as PR CI 1602; that pass does not explain or resolve the failed PR run.

Rust and Markdown jobs pass. Complete logs are retained with no compiler/lint warning candidates. No unchanged retry, cancellation, dispatch or threshold adjustment was performed for this report.

Additional original observations: CI 1733 at cdc13324e2b67039b740e53ad78c03a94de1de41 and CI 1735 at f69b4bc5d36d55069bad0bf7aa8192365651ee94 each pass all 489 catalog VMs, canonical development boot and both native-ls routes before the canonical release wrapper returns 1. Failures occur at 01:56:28 and 03:44:50 UTC on 23 September 2026. Six complete logs total 26,766,524 bytes with zero warning candidates. No inner runner stage or common cause is established, and no retry was performed.

Tracking

This is the release counterpart to development-image issue #40. Preserve the distinction and obtain invocation-correlated runner evidence before assigning a cause. Keep existing boot and cleanup assertions.

Additional original CI classification — 24 September 2026:

  • Run 1771, b3c03a13facae76f9db7d5ab0a860853d655562c, integration job 22392: The canonical release image wrapper exits 1 after canonical development and native launch/input checks pass. Report #47. Three complete logs: 13,382,816 bytes.

Original complete logs and relevant workflow/runner Git blobs verify. Rust and Markdown pass, with zero warning candidates. These observations do not establish an identical cause to the earlier report, an attributed correction or a Kernel regression. All original failures and requirements are retained without retry; this report remains open pending correction evidence.

## Summary The canonical release-image gate returns wrapper status 1 in CI 1595 and CI 1602, after all 486 catalog scenarios, canonical development boot and both native-ls input routes pass. Later interactive release gates are not reached. The underlying runner stage and cause remain unknown. ## Reproduction Observed in retained original CI; no new VM rerun or failure-frequency estimate. ```sh ./tests/release-image-interactive-vm.sh ``` The original workflow prepares its pinned graph and packaged release disk first. The wrapper delegates to canonical-image-vm.sh release, uses a private writable disk and matching OVMF pair, and selects the physical canonical-shell profile. ## Expected and actual behavior Expected behavior is a successful canonical release boot and evidence validation. Actual output is `error: canonical image VM failed with status 1`. The canonical wrapper returns before its evidence parser. The available public log does not identify an injector exit, stall, raw QEMU exit or failed guest command. ## Environment and identity - [CI 1595](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/1595), push, original Integration `37299e719d7662698593c6d3be24752309bed7ec`. - [CI 1602](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/1602), pull_request, original Integration `47c27a1614c02323db7bbebfdbd0ca6b09bc9d45`. The workflow selects its original pinned component graph and x86_64 QEMU/OVMF images. Complete CI logs and original wrappers were inspected. Image/firmware artifact bytes and inner runner receipts were not downloaded; their exact digests and the guest cause remain unverified. Existing 120-second total, 15-second serial-progress and 10-second input-command limits remain unchanged. ## Evidence and prior checks Complete original CI review — 28 September 2026: These are additional original observations. No unchanged job was rerun, and an identical underlying cause to earlier observations is not assumed. - [CI1820](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/1820), `c5958f12daf35ef8c53d8caabaa7429340770179`: Canonical release image wrapper exits 1 before evidence parsing; inner failure stage is unavailable. Three complete logs contain 13,457,954 bytes and zero warning candidates. Rust and Markdown pass. The retained errors occur at 09:30:30 UTC in CI 1595 and 13:15:03 UTC in CI 1602 on September 13. Independent push CI 1601 passes at the same source as PR CI 1602; that pass does not explain or resolve the failed PR run. Rust and Markdown jobs pass. Complete logs are retained with no compiler/lint warning candidates. No unchanged retry, cancellation, dispatch or threshold adjustment was performed for this report. Additional original observations: [CI 1733](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/1733) at `cdc13324e2b67039b740e53ad78c03a94de1de41` and [CI 1735](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/1735) at `f69b4bc5d36d55069bad0bf7aa8192365651ee94` each pass all 489 catalog VMs, canonical development boot and both native-ls routes before the canonical release wrapper returns 1. Failures occur at 01:56:28 and 03:44:50 UTC on 23 September 2026. Six complete logs total 26,766,524 bytes with zero warning candidates. No inner runner stage or common cause is established, and no retry was performed. ## Tracking This is the release counterpart to [development-image issue #40](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/issues/40). Preserve the distinction and obtain invocation-correlated runner evidence before assigning a cause. Keep existing boot and cleanup assertions. Additional original CI classification — 24 September 2026: - [Run 1771](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/actions/runs/1771), `b3c03a13facae76f9db7d5ab0a860853d655562c`, integration job 22392: The canonical release image wrapper exits 1 after canonical development and native launch/input checks pass. [Report #47](https://git.erikinkinen.fi/erix/integration/issues/47). Three complete logs: 13,382,816 bytes. Original complete logs and relevant workflow/runner Git blobs verify. Rust and Markdown pass, with zero warning candidates. These observations do not establish an identical cause to the earlier report, an attributed correction or a Kernel regression. All original failures and requirements are retained without retry; this report remains open pending correction evidence.
erikinkinen added this to the Alpha 1 milestone 2026-10-30 09:34:14 +01:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
erix/integration#47
No description provided.