Protocol: accept the declared diagnostic and source inventories #669
Open
erikinkinen
wants to merge 12 commits from
fix/protocol-2.2-closed-enums into main
pull from: fix/protocol-2.2-closed-enums
merge into: erikinkinen:main
erikinkinen:main
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-11-workload-acceptance
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-14-e-decision-ledgers
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-12-b-run-manifests
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-11-c-paired-controls
erikinkinen:fix/670-sanitizer-suite-budget
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-21-a-sel4-environment
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-14-d-survival
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-14-c-descriptive-statistics
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-14-b-cluster-resampling
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-12-a-protocol-dispatch
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-18-a-lean-types
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-11-b-deleted-bridge
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-661-optimized-debug-smoke
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-11-a-lineage-swap
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-655-ci-suite-budget
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-653-sanitizer-profile
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-14-a-analysis-environment
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-09-immutable-intent-tapes
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-649-sanitizer-job-budget
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-646-strict-schema-terminators
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-08-replay-acceptance
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-08-c-preserved-tamper-corpus
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-08-b-state-hash-resume
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-641-moved-oracle-fixture-indexes
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-08-a-operation-replay
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-638-moved-holder-oracle
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-07-event-codec-acceptance
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-07-b-v4-codec
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-635-formatter-version
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-632-jsonl-numeric-grammar
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-07-a-research-event-types
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-629-engine-overflow-guards
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-10-static-projection
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-06-instrumentation-acceptance
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-06-c-counter-conservation
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-06-b-access-delegation-counters
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-06-a-resolver-mutation-counters
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-621-atomic-revocation
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-05-operation-counters
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-04-usable-authority
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-03-external-policy
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-617-current-sanitizer-runtime
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-614-sanitizer-consumers
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-02-preserve-legacy
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-612-relative-figure-paths
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-610-rights-header
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-608-workload-family-regeneration
erikinkinen:phase2/p2-01-freeze-protocol
erikinkinen:phase2/bug-605-local-hooks
erikinkinen:1-experiment-hygiene-and-threats-to-validity-checks-39
erikinkinen:1-detect-and-surface-overlapping-identical-strategy-curves-80
erikinkinen:1-strategy-differentiating-revocation-artifacts-and-figure-pipeline
erikinkinen:1-plot-and-figure-generation-pipeline
erikinkinen:1-batch-runner-for-phase-1-sweeps
erikinkinen:1-revocation-outcome-metrics
erikinkinen:1-revocation-focused-workloads
erikinkinen:1-strategy-equivalence-and-sanity-checks
erikinkinen:1-strategy-d-epoch-indirection-revocation
erikinkinen:1-strategy-c-lineage-based-revocation-basic
erikinkinen:1-strategy-b-lazy-invalidate-on-use-revocation
erikinkinen:1-strategy-a-eager-traversal-revocation
erikinkinen:1-revocation-strategy-interface
erikinkinen:1-revocation-cost-accounting-framework
erikinkinen:1-ground-truth-revocation-oracle
erikinkinen:1-revocation-event-types-and-api
erikinkinen:1-capability-use-semantics
erikinkinen:1-phase1-specification-and-invariants
erikinkinen:0-phase0-documentation
erikinkinen:0-determinism-and-invariant-test-suite
erikinkinen:0-cli-simulate-and-export
erikinkinen:0-metrics-framework
erikinkinen:0-residual-authority-detection-baseline
erikinkinen:0-ground-truth-reachability-analysis
erikinkinen:0-snapshot-hashing-and-equality
erikinkinen:0-replay-and-snapshot-reconstruction
erikinkinen:0-event-log-format-v0
erikinkinen:0-workloads
erikinkinen:0-workload-generator-interface
erikinkinen:0-deterministic-simulation-engine
erikinkinen:0-graph-delta-format
erikinkinen:0-event-application-api
erikinkinen:0-event-taxonomy-v0
erikinkinen:0-graph-indexing-and-integrity
erikinkinen:0-capability-edge-representation
erikinkinen:0-subject-and-object-node-storage
erikinkinen:0-authority-model-specification
erikinkinen:0-fix-formatting
erikinkinen:0-stable-id-types-and-utilities
erikinkinen:0-repository-scaffold-and-conventions
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
bug
cli
core
docs
event
experiment
figure
invariant
metrics
oracle
phase-0
phase-1
phase-2
phase-3
phase-4
phase-5
phase-6
provenance
revocation
tests
workload
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set
Reference
erikinkinen/AES!669
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "fix/protocol-2.2-closed-enums"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Closes #666.
Current CI-only integration
Plan ID:
BUG-666. Current integration head:128fb39b072ed39fdb5e517775089c8b230a963e.Selected predecessor: #108 / PR #668 at
145abd989a92f5707d03c339b411520009b57c83. Its current state isopen;predecessor acceptance is required before this PR's checklist and merge.
This signed update changes exactly the sanitizer overall timeout, its
documentation and two CI failure-evidence files. All original owned outputs,
integrated build configurations and source/acceptance/integration JSON records
are byte-identical. Existing source and local integration validations retain
their original execution heads and scope. The failed 90-minute attempts remain
failed attempts; this head requires all ten new final remote checks.
CI budget qualification, SHA-256
2a24aa55e60b193c315a3ebe1c39fc34717cadbf4f67f2a1b5041be6962d93e1, establishes full 496-test pinned-consumer capacityfor #670. This PR's complete 497-test suite still requires its own new remote
checks. No scientific input, parser/planner meaning, bound or estimand changed.
Original source and integration evidence
Task
Closes #666
Summary
Align the protocol 2.2 common envelope with its exact fifteen diagnostics and
twelve source IDs. Accept V5d and the five section-4.5 source IDs; reject
undeclared V2c and malformed near-neighbors in both native parsing and JSON Schema.
Scope
Included
Explicitly excluded
Design intent
The common envelope recognizes declared IDs across phases2–6. Later stage gates
still enforce applicability. The Phase2 diagnostic planner rejects every other
source and an appended V5d, with no output creation or workload execution.
Phase discipline
This fixes the accepted common-envelope implementation to the frozen protocol.
All historical acceptance records retain their original source identities.
Verification
Source
4e007880da782cdcd46c0e12741696cbf18e5e8epasses parser/schema and complete structuralplanner fixtures in Release, Debug-O1 and Clang ASan/UBSan: 254 parser negative
cases, 28 planner negative cases, 40 config-schema negatives, all thirteen
stage dispatch cases and 13,104 complete planned rows/configurations. Eight
original baseline cases are retained and reexecuted under all three profiles;
the fixed expected outcomes and canonical stdout agree. Zero workloads execute.
Original failure and source evidence has SHA-256
ffc6dab648225fc90fc0484a70ed788545f3e5f1981e00813a857a1fc207ea70.Integration
a45096fd37c85362efcb697760b4e1b8a5363ccechanges only six predecessor receipt JSON files relativeto the local source acceptance. All owned implementation/schema/docs/fixtures
and build files remain unchanged. The current497-test inventory is identical;
both focused tests pass afresh. All eight hooks and frozen scope checks pass.
Integration evidence has SHA-256
301fa26987c663c3b6bf07876facc7023b0ef891e70b2145fd6aefae14142f1a. Both complete final remote497-test suites andthe remaining six contexts are mandatory; no complete local497-test run is claimed.
Notes
This PR is queued behind PR #668 at
fcbbdf6d088ccc39322d81e4aaae3dd4af9d14c6to overlap CI.Until it merges, the comparison with main includes the pending predecessor
stack. Require its accepted exact-head CI and closed issue #108, then all ten
own final exact-head contexts. Only afterward check all three issue #666 items
once and perform the guarded signed fast-forward merge. Native #107 is closed.
Acceptance record completion
Signed head
8712d6b0ddd80fcc2ff311c074f1c3eaca0b73cbadds section17.4's required commands inventory fromeleven already archived successful command records.
acceptance-completion.jsonverifies their original log hashes and preservesall implementation, schema, fixture and original integration-receipt bytes.
No additional source validation is claimed. All ten final contexts are required
on this new head before the three issue items can be checked once.
b25aa19d15' into phase2/p2-14-d-survival 496ecb397d496ecb397d' into phase2/p2-21-a-sel4-environment 4cfa5c84bcView command line instructions
Checkout
From your project repository, check out a new branch and test the changes.